Thursday 9 June 2016

Presstitute’s freedom for fame!

This is a reply to Ipsita Chakravarty’s article “Dilli Chalo: A protest that began in Manipur has found a new epicenter in the capital” in Scroll. I am neither the custodian of Manipur society nor defender of the Meetei. I am taking my busy schedule to educate Ms Ipsita a little knowledge of Manipur which she ignored while favouring one side. It was an interview of some culprits and their sympathizers who were prevented by Delhi Police from committing a murder! 
Delhi Police controlling the Mob which came to lynch leaders at Manipur Bhawan (Photo - ANI)

Ms. Ipsita is the second writer and third bengali who’s compromising with the genuine history of the region. First, it was Shantidas Gosai, a Bengali Brahmin from Sylhet in united Bengal. Mr. Gosai ‘s entry into Manipur in the early parts of 18th century begins the downfall of our Meetei kingdom. Few days back, another presstitute, Esha Roy of Indian Express published an article based on a photograph which goes viral in Social Media, without further verification of the source and confirmation from the Forensic Lab of the image she used to web a story sabotaging the ILP movement in Manipur. 

Now, Ms. Ipsita again has cooked a story. It seems both Esha Roy and Ipsita Chakravarty have same genetic links with Shantidas Gosai of 18th Century. Both are against Meetei! May be they were told that the Meetei killed that Gosai in the end. 

Ms. Ipsita, your article must be called a “Tribal’s voice in Delhi” or “Mouth piece of Manipur Tribal Forum Delhi (MTFD)”. Have you cross checked the culprits identity that were beaten for attempt to kill the Delhi Police officers? First check their Nationality, from which State they belong? Were they from Manipur, Mizoram or Nagaland? Or are they from Myanmar? And on what basis you used the word “peaceful” protestors? Were you present on the spot of lathi-charge? Did you asked the statement of the Delhi Police to reconstruct the event for your write ups? 

The Chief Minister of Manipur and delegations of political leaders do not have to meet every Tom Dick and Harry in Delhi? The “All Party Delegations” have gone to Delhi to meet the Prime Minister and his Council of Union Ministers. Who authorized MTFD to represent the JAC of so called anti Tribal Bills? Asked to the MTFD why the Churachandpur JAC not ready for talk with the government back home? 

The Government of Manipur (GOM) and Joint Committee on Inner Line Permit System (JCILPS) have been inviting the Chrurachandpur JAC for discussions and several CSO have invited them for debate on why these tribal called the 3 Bills of Manipur “Anti Tribals”.

Have you asked those agitators in Delhi why, instead of discussion on the 3 Bills, they are demanding for a separate administration for the Hills. Or separation from Manipur Valley? Those culprits were timely prevented by Delhi Police before storming into Manipur Bhawan. Their plan was to lynch our political leaders and burnt down Manipur Bhawan.

If you need the footage of peaceful protestors and their hooglism slogans, I may provide the video clipping , enjoy it while eating some pork curry in a Nagaland or Mizoram Bhawan. 

Ms. Ipsita, if you really care to know about the 3 Bills, Manipur unrest and all those drama behind not burying those 9 killed in Churachandpur, browse some official documents as well. Have you asked to the MTFD how those nine were killed and what they want, why they not allowed the Investigations by a reputed agencies, even if they don’t trust the Manipur administration? 

Next time go and verified to the MTFD that out of the 9 deads, 2 were charred to death when the mob burnt houses of Tribal MLAs, 1 got killed in an accident, 2 killed by Kuki militants, 4 were killed by Police when they tried to storm and burnt down the Police Station. Do you think they are fit to be called martyrs and do you agree they are killed by Meetei. Asked who gave order to shoot? A tribal Deputy Commissioner (DC) and a Tribal Superintendent of Police (SP) was in charge of Churachandpur at the time the mob unrest. It was Tribal Home Minister and Tribal Chief Secretary too. Why the MTFD don’t spill out such facts to you? 

Also discuss these points next time when you meet any Tribals who talked of discrimination by Meetei or valley people. You should know the grounds reality that Meetei are being harassed and discriminated by Tribals only. Manipur is composed of 90 percent hills and 4 percent valley, 6 percent water body (lake). Meeteis are living along with all these tribes in as little as 4 percent valley only. 

These valley lands once purchased by tribal cannot be sold to a Meetei without the approval of the Deputy Commissioner. And Meetei cannot buy lands in the hills. Meetei never complained of blockades in Highway by Tribals, looting and collecting illegal taxes from every trucks and buses playing in the National Highway by Tribals. 

Have you ever do a research and write on such discrimination by the Tribals to the Meetei. More than 2 lakhs Meetei voters out of the total 8 voters in the Outer parliamentary seat do not get the privilege to contest elections, but just cast their votes. Where in Indian state, such discrimination are found to a particularly community? 

If those barbaric culprits were beaten by Delhi Police, why the MTFD and JAC against the  3 Bills called for 24 hours total shutdown of  hills in Manipur? Ask to them why they torturing the innocent brothers and sisters of the hills?  Do you have any idea that the JAC have also called for Economic blockades in the National Highways of Manipur?

Consult your friends and counter my reply. We would be happy to debate on this too. The more you write on their behalf, more truth will be exposed to the World!